|
BALNEOTHERAPY
AND SPA THERAPY FOR OSTEOARTHRITIS
M. Zeki Karagulle
Department of Medical Ecology and Hydroclimatology
Istanbul Medical Faculty of Istanbul University
Istanbul, Turkey
Osteoarthritis
(OA) isalready the most prevalent disorder of joints in the world and
is likely to increase in prevalence. Although the exact mechanism of
OA is still not fully known, it appears to be the result of an imbalance
between synthesis and degradation of articular cartilage, its extracellular
matrix and subchondral bone, thus leading to loss of integrity. The
most common sites of OA are the hands, knees, hips, cervical and lumbrosacral
spine and less frequently the shoulders and elbows. Joint involvement
is usually unilateral and systemic manifestations are rare. Current
treatment of OA is dominated by drug therapy, with paracetamol and selective
and non-selective nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs. It is becoming
more evident that drug treatment is inappropriate for OA, as symptoms
are mostly driven by mechanical and psychosocial factors.
There
are efforts for improving recent management strategies of OA including
American College of Rheumatology (ACR) Subcommittee on Osteoarthritis
Guidelines and a task force for the European League Against Rheumatism
(EULAR) Standing Committee for Clinical Trials. The recommended approach
to the medical management of hip or knee OA by the Subcommittee on OA
Guidelines of ACR includes nonpharmacological modalities and drug therapy.
The components of nonpharmacological therapy do not specifically include
balneotherapy or spa therapy. But some modalities are also components
of contemporary complex spa therapy such as patient education, aerobic
and muscle-strengthening exercises. Recommendations of the EULAR Task
Force reflect an evidence-based approach to key clinical questions concerning
the treatment of knee OA. Spa therapy is included among the nonpharmacological
interventions selected for assessment. A total of four OA papers were
assessed and of which, three of them reported positive results compared
to control. In one study, effect size could be calculated as 0.47 but
the quality of trials was moderate (median: 14.5, range: 12-17, possible
max. score 28). Category of evidence was assessed according to study
design which reflected susceptibility to bias. Evidence for spa therapy
for knee OA was categorized as 1B reflecting strong evidence obtained
from at least one randomised controlled trial. But the strength of recommendation
for spa therapy was graded C (range A-D) by the four members of editing
subcommittee of the task force. This is an extrapolated recommendation
from category 1 or 2 evidence and seems to be an underestimated one.
Finally, overall opinion of all experts on the usefulness of spa therapy
(expressed by a VAS scale of 0-100 ) reveals that spa therapy is not
strongly recommended (mean VAS score 30). This is not in accordance
with good evidence (1B) that spa therapy is beneficial in the management
of knee OA.
Balneotherapy
and/or spa therapy are the oldest form of therapy that have been used
for centuries in the management of musculoskeletal disorders. Balneotherapy
of modern times may be defined as “the therapeutic use of mineral and
thermal waters, usually through water immersion of part or all of the
body, but also through drinking certain amount of water and inhaling
the vaporized or dispersed water. “Balneo” comes from the Latin word
for bath- “balneum”. It refers to bathing in thermal or mineral waters.
Almost
all ancient civilizations used natural thermal and mineral water therapies,
which later became a central focus of many health-promoting establishments
such as spas. In English language “Spa” is a specific word for ‘place
with thermal baths’ or ‘health resorts’. One of the most important activities
that take place at a traditional or modern spa is balneotherapy. In
addition to balneotherapeutic use of waters, gases such as CO2 and radon,
muds such as peat or clay and climatic factors such as atmospheric temperature
or UV light are often used as part of a complex spa therapy. A ‘natural’
approach to health and healing has developed by using these components
which are specific to spas for therapeutic purposes. These watering
places evolved the term spa therapy.
There
have been many anecdotal claims of beneficial effects of balneotherapy
and/or spa therapy especially for pain relief in arthritic conditions
such as osteoarthritis. But, until recently, there have not been many
trials on the efficacy of balneotherapy and spa therapy in general for
osteoarthritis that apply modern clinical trial methodology and standardized
outcome measures. Last decade, several randomised controlled trials
(RCTs) have published in peer-reviewed journals in English reporting
modest short and long-term effects in reducing pain and improving functional
indexes. Most of these trials have studied the effects of spa therapy
in patients with knee OA. Currently, there are scarce RCTs on hip, spine
and hand osteoarthritis that report positive results on the effectiveness
of spa therapy.
It
is hoped that in the near future, there will be more pharmacological
and nonpharmacological options available in the management of OA. Balneotherapy
and spa therapy is such an option which may gain more importance and
acceptance when more scientific evidences are available to explain their
effects on the pathophysiology of osteoarthritis and to confirm their
therapeutic efficacy in osteoarthritis and musculoskeletal conditions.
|